Skip to content

We Can Remember It for You Wholesale

Overview

We Can Remember It for You Wholesale (1966; Fantasy & Science Fiction, April 1966) is the basis of the 1990 film Total Recall. Douglas Quail, a minor clerk, wants to visit Mars. He purchases a memory implant from Rekal Inc. — an artificial "vacation memory" of a trip he never took. During the implant process, the technicians discover he already has memories of Mars that are only partially erased: memories of being a secret agent. Trying to suppress the implant, the government agents who erased the first memory find it layered over a second, deeper memory — a boyhood fantasy of saving Earth from alien invasion that, somehow, may be literally true.

The story ends with each layer of reality protection collapsing as soon as it is examined. No stable ground is ever reached. The clerk's wish-fulfillment is real; his manufactured wish-fulfillment replaced an actual experience; his actual experience replaced a desire that predates it. Identity becomes a geological problem.

The Spielberg/Schwarzenegger film adaptation recapitulates the structure while resolving the ambiguity — the story deliberately does not.

Dick wrote several more short stories in late 1965 and into 1966 during the same period; this story and "Holy Quarrel" arrived at his literary agency on the same day in September 1965.

Reusable Design Patterns

Memory as commodity. Memories can be purchased, installed, and — imperfectly — erased. This is not metaphor; it is infrastructure. Any restoration loop implies the same: each resurrection cycle selects which memories to restore and which to suppress. That selection is a political act.

Layered revelation structure. The story's structure is a nested set: apparent false memory conceals real experience conceals earlier false memory conceals something older still. For campaign design, this is a pacing model: the "answer" to a PC's backstory question always reveals another layer. The question is never fully resolved — only the current layer is exposed.

Death-loop memory forensics. What memories did the previous iteration carry? Are they complete? Were they edited before restore? A PC who survived multiple cycles may have memories that contradict each other — artifacts of edits that didn't fully take.

Backstory as manufactured. PCs may discover their own history is fabricated. The revelation is not "you were lied to about events" but "the memories themselves are synthetic." This turns the entire prior campaign into forensic evidence.

The Interplan parallel. The government agents in the story are not sinister masterminds — they are procedural bureaucrats trying to contain a memory leak. The threat to the protagonist is systemic, not personal. No villain is required.

Referee Uses

  • The vat-restore audit: a session built around discovering that a PC's post-resurrection memories include events they cannot verify — some real, some possibly edited
  • Memory merchant NPC: a faction service that offers memory purchase or targeted erasure; the PCs are customers or targets, depending on the session
  • Layered-backstory campaign structure: reveal PC history in geological layers — each revelation unlocks a deeper one; never close the loop
  • The hidden agent: a PC (or NPC) who believes themselves to be an ordinary person but whose deleted operational memories are leaking as déjà vu, skills they shouldn't have, contacts who recognize them
  • Faction memory warfare: competing factions try to install, preserve, or delete specific memories in a target PC — the PC's identity becomes a contested resource

See Also